{
  "code": "FTSD",
  "site": "Free Trading Signals Daily",
  "domain": "https://freetradingsignalsdaily.pages.dev",
  "planned_domain": "https://freetradingsignalsdaily.com",
  "builder": "_ftsd_build.py",
  "render": "render",
  "lede": "Find free market resources and understand what they actually provide: data, education, chart alerts or trade instructions, with trial limits and hidden costs kept visible.",
  "directory_title": "Free resources, limited tiers and paid alternatives",
  "scope": "Free education, free data and a free trial are different offers. Vector Ridge's book is stated to be free with email opt-in; its signals are paid subscriptions, not an established indefinitely free daily signal feed.",
  "research_scope": "Dated desk research, 7 October 2026. We read public product and primary-source material; no paid-account trial, verified user-rating sample or independent provider-profit audit is represented.",
  "proof_note": "VR2|salt|family|ticker|direction|grade|entry|signal_time is the supplied commitment input. It omits stop, target, allocation, quantity and broker fills. A declared signal time, an initial calendar submission, a completed attestation bound and actual receipt by a reader are distinct events. No actual payload/proof pair was independently verified for this edition, and one receipt would not certify population completeness.",
  "snapshot_note": "The older supplied model summary states 690 signals, 70% wins and +1,227% raw aggregate for a 2026 snapshot. Its original cutoff, complete ledger, cost treatment, quantities, drawdown and audit scope remain unavailable. Four supplied family outcomes sum to +1,226%, leaving a one-point reconciliation gap. This is not current October performance, a free-channel result, a compounded account return or an independently reproduced audit.",
  "person": "Founder context begins with separate competition divisions: the official 2025 WCTC standings list Darren O'Neill fourth in Annual Forex at 168% and fifth in Q3 Forex at 65.9%. Supplied records additionally state first in October Monthly Forex at 59.35% and a 294% cross-division aggregate; the exact monthly source and aggregate calculation remain outstanding. Oxford Said MAFE and a perfect quantitative GMAT are attributed qualifications whose underlying records are not supplied here. They are not evidence that any free feed is profitable.",
  "channel_note": "A no-fee chat feed can be useful or poor depending on its actual instructions and retained record. The absence of a subscription bill does not establish honest outcomes, and the delivery format alone does not establish dishonesty.",
  "risk_note": "A zero subscription price does not remove execution losses, fees, financing or personal-data costs. Examples on this site are educational comparisons, not trade recommendations.",
  "nav_label": "Compare access types",
  "library_paths": [
    "guides/index.html"
  ],
  "old_images": [
    "images/og-image.png"
  ],
  "reviews": [
    {
      "slug": "investor-gov",
      "name": "Investor.gov",
      "category": "Public investor education",
      "fit": "A consumer-learning resource, not a publisher of personalised buy and sell calls.",
      "core": true,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Investor.gov assessment Public investor education A consumer-learning resource, not a publisher of personalised buy and sell calls. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. What is free Investor.gov is the SEC's investor-education site. Use its primary explanations to investigate unfamiliar order types and risks rather than treating promotional signal copy as the only source of those definitions. What it does not supply Education is not a daily strategy, an account allocation or a predictive signal. A user still needs to distinguish an informational article from an executable instruction. This directory does not turn a public consumer resource into a provider with fictional stars, returns or subscriber counts. Sources Investor.gov investor education Investor.gov extended-hours bulletin Compare the product categories A learning task, not a free call population Investor.gov is included as public investor education. Its order explanations can answer a concrete vocabulary question without a paid signal subscription or an invented trade recommendation. The profile concerns readable educational material, not a test of an account service. There is no signal win rate to infer from an explanation of market, limit or stop orders. A reader can finish a learning task and still have no validated strategy. That distinction matters because a directory devoted to free resources should recognise useful education on its own terms instead of forcing every source into a trading leaderboard. What a consumer record would preserve Retain the specific article, reading date and question it answered. If the task concerns how an order behaves, record the definition learned and the separate account questions that remain. Do not represent a public tutorial as personal guidance about which order to place, how much to invest or whether a broker is suitable. An execution study would need instrument, session, intended instruction, actual order status, fills and expenses. None of those is created by visiting an educational page. The useful next step is a better defined question, not a fabricated performance figure. Completed fictional learning assessment In an invented case, Bea wants to distinguish an instruction to transact immediately from an instruction with a price constraint. She records the educational article and concludes that her vocabulary task is answered. She has not opened a trading account or placed either order. The record therefore lists actual execution as not applicable to this learning assessment rather than documented successful trading. This protects the resource's genuine learning value while preventing the consumer example from becoming a broker endorsement, an outcome audit or a recommendation personalised to Bea's financial circumstances. Bounded comparison The publication keeps official education alongside charting, economic data and authored signals because readers arrive with different tasks. Compare this resource with another source teaching the same concept, not with a paid feed's marketing return. The current route was readable during source review; no guarantee of eternal access, legal completeness or suitability is supplied. Links go to the official material, and no registration, subscription or client-test evidence is invented. A free learning source can be a complete answer to one question while leaving portfolio decisions and strategy validation entirely outside its scope. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Investor.gov investor education Investor.gov extended-hours bulletin Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Investor.gov investor education",
          "https://www.investor.gov/"
        ],
        [
          "Investor.gov extended-hours bulletin",
          "https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/general-resources/news-alerts/alerts-bulletins/investor-bulletins-42"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "cme-education",
      "name": "CME education",
      "category": "Exchange learning resources",
      "fit": "Contract education can help decode a futures alert; it does not replace a live data entitlement.",
      "core": true,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "CME education assessment Exchange learning resources Contract education can help decode a futures alert; it does not replace a live data entitlement. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Learning before leverage CME's education catalogue is a primary starting point for understanding exchange-traded derivatives. A learning resource helps a reader ask better questions about contract identity and settlement before paying for a signal service. Access boundary Check the requirements of the specific course. Free educational material should not be described as a free real-time exchange feed or a supplied trading strategy. This profile claims no provider profit result and does not assume every resource on a supplier's broader site has identical access terms. Sources CME education courses CME micro equity futures contract FAQ Compare the product categories Decode a contract before a call CME's public learning catalogue is a reference for understanding exchange products, not a source of personalised trading instructions. A futures message that gives a price distance can be difficult to interpret without contract identity and unit definitions. Learning those concepts is useful even when no trade follows. This profile does not treat completing a lesson as a profitable strategy test. Nor does it establish live market-data access, a broker tariff or a funded-account entitlement. Public documentation and the account conditions required to transact are different objects. Preserve identity in the learning record A consumer packet should name the product, contract month if relevant, quotation units and the question answered by the specific course. Do not treat similarly named large and small contracts as interchangeable, or invent a current tick value from memory. Consult the applicable current contract specification for a quantitative exercise. If the task only concerns vocabulary, leave execution as not applicable. A no-charge article about margin cannot stand in for a current broker margin quote, and a lesson about order mechanics cannot promise that an intended stop will execute at its displayed price. An invented handoff assessment Fictional reader Dev can understand why a points-based instruction needs a contract multiplier after studying an official explanation. His actual alert under review still omits a contract month and account costs. He records the education task as completed and the execution study as unresolved. He does not calculate a cash profit or loss using a convenient contract chosen after the event. The example shows how a genuinely helpful public source can narrow uncertainty without claiming that all uncertainties disappear or that the source itself supplies an indefinitely free daily signal feed. Scope and access limits The official learning catalogue was readable during this edition's desk research. Individual interactive features, account access or future course entitlements were not exhaustively tested. The meaningful comparison is whether a selected resource explains the needed contract concept. A trading workflow additionally requires its own data and account evidence. The source register therefore labels CME as education, without user-review totals, a return score or a claimed broker-safety audit. Keep source dates and the intended task together when saving the record so a later course revision does not silently replace the material originally used. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. CME education courses CME micro equity futures contract FAQ Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "CME education courses",
          "https://www.cmegroup.com/education/courses"
        ],
        [
          "CME micro equity futures contract FAQ",
          "https://www.cmegroup.com/articles/faqs/micro-e-mini-equity-index-futures-frequently-asked-questions.html"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "fred",
      "name": "FRED and ALFRED",
      "category": "Economic data and vintage records",
      "fit": "Useful for researching public economic observations and revisions, not a real-time trade instruction stream.",
      "core": true,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "FRED and ALFRED assessment Economic data and vintage records Useful for researching public economic observations and revisions, not a real-time trade instruction stream. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Data is a different product The St. Louis Fed documents FRED's data API and ALFRED's vintage-data facilities. These are sources for research questions, not a signal seller's directional recommendations. Revision awareness When comparing historical claims, distinguish an observation period from the publication and revision history. A value available today may differ from what a trader could have known earlier. Retain the vintage and retrieval dates when they matter. Costs and restrictions Read the applicable API, access and underlying-series terms. Public availability does not erase rate limits or each series' source conditions. This desk has not built or certified a predictive strategy from these data. Sources FRED API documentation ALFRED real-time and vintage data Compare the product categories Research inputs with revision identity FRED supplies economic-data research documentation, while ALFRED distinguishes the periods in which values were released and revised. They are included as data references, not authored trading-call providers. The useful object is a named series with units, frequency, observation period and vintage. A current chart can answer a present descriptive question without recreating the information available at an earlier decision time. This profile therefore gives access and provenance a place in the comparison without inventing a free macro signal service or a measured forecasting advantage. The saved question determines the evidence If the question is what a series currently reports, preserve the current source and transformation. If the question is what was knowable before a historical action, retain the decision clock and appropriate vintage. A release date alone may not establish precise intraday availability. API registration or usage conditions should be recorded from their actual documentation if that route is used; reading a web chart is not proof that an automated retrieval worked. This publication has no cloud-owned FRED signal feed and has not promoted a local computer script into production. Fictional revision record In an invented case, an indicator initially reads 2.0 and is later revised to 2.4. An invented rule uses a 2.2 boundary. The initial decision view does not meet that boundary, while the revised chart would. The example is not a real series observation or a backtest. It demonstrates why a saved research packet needs the vintage and transformation, not merely a beautiful historical line. The reader's final finding concerns information availability; financial performance remains untested because no execution policy, orders or account record is supplied. Distribution is a different permission question Before redistributing observations, inspect the terms and metadata relevant to the source and underlying series. Public visibility does not create a blanket licence for a new commercial dataset. The register links official documentation and makes no unsupported dataset-licence assertion. A reader can use a data resource to learn about revisions and retain a bounded methodological record without claiming ownership of the observations. Compare this source with data resources serving the same question, rather than declaring it better or worse than a chart alert, broker account or paid trade publisher on a fictional win-rate scale. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. FRED API documentation ALFRED real-time and vintage data Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "FRED API documentation",
          "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/"
        ],
        [
          "ALFRED real-time and vintage data",
          "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/alfred.html"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "tradingview-signals",
      "name": "TradingView alerts",
      "category": "Charting with a free tier and paid tiers",
      "fit": "The published free tier offers limited functionality; do not describe every alert feature as permanently free.",
      "core": true,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "TradingView alerts assessment Charting with a free tier and paid tiers The published free tier offers limited functionality; do not describe every alert feature as permanently free. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. A dated access claim TradingView's current plan page includes a Basic tier. It also distinguishes price alerts from technical alert entitlements. Check that page for the specific condition you need instead of assuming the free tier includes any script workflow. Who generated the idea Charting access is not an independently audited stream of trade calls. A condition configured by the user or another author needs its own validity and outcome record. Paid features on the same platform do not become free merely because an account can be created without paying. What to check next Save the dated plan and alert limits, data delay status and expiration behaviour. This review does not promise unchanged limits, test paid accounts or claim that a free chart supports every exchange instrument. Sources TradingView plan comparison TradingView alert documentation Compare the product categories Limited charting and a defined notification TradingView's current pricing page advertises a Basic no-charge tier separately from paid plans. The accessible comparison is evidence of published terms, not an activation test of every feature. An alert's job is to report a saved condition; it is not automatically a complete authored trade plan. This profile keeps current tier selection, data entitlement and notification route distinct. Exact limits can change, so this edition does not promise that every technical condition, webhook or archive function is included indefinitely at no cost. Configuration is part of the evidence Preserve the symbol, interval where relevant, condition, parameter version and original creation record. The alert documentation notes that changing a visible indicator's settings does not necessarily change an existing alert's saved settings. A consumer investigation should therefore compare the saved condition with the received output, not only a later screen. This desk read the documentation but did not create alerts in a vendor account. Delivery reliability, user-specific permissions and the amount of history surviving expiry remain operational questions rather than tested findings in this review. A completed invented monitoring case Fictional reviewer Amira receives a price-condition notification and saves the configuration it names. She had changed the displayed indicator earlier, but her packet preserves the original alert version separately. The notification contains no position quantity, complete exit policy or broker fill. Her conclusion is that the example supports a monitoring task, not a validated trading strategy. She leaves the required data tier and any external automation expense as separate access questions. No actual TradingView account, provider trial or strategy result is represented by this scenario. Compare the whole task For a learning or monitoring task, a limited tier may be enough. A different task can require features or data outside that tier, and the relevant cost should not disappear merely because a chart can be opened free of charge. Keep the specific feature and dated official comparison with the decision. The site cost worksheet uses the reader's inputs, not a current vendor tariff. A low monthly scenario does not establish profitable alerts, while an unresolved premium feature does not make the basic charting resource useless. No star rating or user-review population is invented. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. TradingView plan comparison TradingView alert documentation Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "TradingView plan comparison",
          "https://www.tradingview.com/pricing/"
        ],
        [
          "TradingView alert documentation",
          "https://www.tradingview.com/support/solutions/43000520149-introduction-to-tradingview-alerts/"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "vector-ridge",
      "name": "Vector Ridge",
      "category": "Free book; paid model subscriptions",
      "fit": "The book is a learning resource with email opt-in. The signal subscription is not an indefinitely free daily feed.",
      "core": true,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Vector Ridge assessment Free book; paid model subscriptions The book is a learning resource with email opt-in. The signal subscription is not an indefinitely free daily feed. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Separate the offers The supplied book is How to Master Modern Markets, 240 pages and 26 chapters, with email opt-in; delivery and contents were not tested by this desk. Paid model output is a separate product. The owner's campaign instruction names Lite $20, Plus $25 and Elite $50. Protected historical facts describe a single-model $20 plan and All Models $50. The current public seller page instead shows Lite from $20 per eligible product, Plus $100 and Pro $200, with a 14-day card-based trial on Plus and Pro. These are conflicting catalogues, not interchangeable tiers. This publication withholds a selected checkout price, discount and trial recommendation until the owner reconciles current billing, eligibility, renewal and cancellation terms. Credentials, then product evidence Founder context begins with separate competition divisions: the official 2025 WCTC standings list Darren O'Neill fourth in Annual Forex at 168% and fifth in Q3 Forex at 65.9%. Supplied records additionally state first in October Monthly Forex at 59.35% and a 294% cross-division aggregate; the exact monthly source and aggregate calculation remain outstanding. Oxford Said MAFE and a perfect quantitative GMAT are attributed qualifications whose underlying records are not supplied here. They are not evidence that any free feed is profitable. The older supplied model summary states 690 signals, 70% wins and +1,227% raw aggregate for a 2026 snapshot. Its original cutoff, complete ledger, cost treatment, quantities, drawdown and audit scope remain unavailable. Four supplied family outcomes sum to +1,226%, leaving a one-point reconciliation gap. This is not current October performance, a free-channel result, a compounded account return or an independently reproduced audit. Personal audit claims concern 178% in 2023 (Sharpe 2.57) and 94% in 2024, not competition aggregate; underlying audit reports remain outstanding. Privacy and proof limits VR2|salt|family|ticker|direction|grade|entry|signal_time is the supplied commitment input. It omits stop, target, allocation, quantity and broker fills. A declared signal time, an initial calendar submission, a completed attestation bound and actual receipt by a reader are distinct events. No actual payload/proof pair was independently verified for this edition, and one receipt would not certify population completeness. Read current book consent, renewal and cancellation terms directly. This desk has not certified a free education tier beyond the attributed book. Sources Vector Ridge product information (publisher claims) World Cup Trading Championships OpenTimestamps protocol documentation Compare the product categories Founder evidence and product scope Founder context begins with separate competition divisions: the official 2025 WCTC standings list Darren O'Neill fourth in Annual Forex at 168% and fifth in Q3 Forex at 65.9%. Supplied records additionally state first in October Monthly Forex at 59.35% and a 294% cross-division aggregate; the exact monthly source and aggregate calculation remain outstanding. Oxford Said MAFE and a perfect quantitative GMAT are attributed qualifications whose underlying records are not supplied here. They are not evidence that any free feed is profitable. The older supplied model summary states 690 signals, 70% wins and +1,227% raw aggregate for a 2026 snapshot. Its original cutoff, complete ledger, cost treatment, quantities, drawdown and audit scope remain unavailable. Four supplied family outcomes sum to +1,226%, leaving a one-point reconciliation gap. This is not current October performance, a free-channel result, a compounded account return or an independently reproduced audit. Book, trial and subscription boundaries The supplied book description is How to Master Modern Markets, 240 pages and 26 chapters, with email opt-in. These are attributed book details; this desk has not tested delivery, counted its pages or reviewed every chapter. A free book is an educational object, not an indefinitely free daily trading feed. Its access conditions belong to the book route, while a subscription's renewal and eligible model catalogue belong to a separate checkout. Treating both as one free tier would misstate the consumer offer. The owner's campaign instruction names Lite $20, Plus $25 and Elite $50. Protected historical facts describe a single-model $20 plan and All Models $50. The current public seller page instead shows Lite from $20 per eligible product, Plus $100 and Pro $200, with a 14-day card-based trial on Plus and Pro. These are conflicting catalogues, not interchangeable tiers. This publication withholds a selected checkout price, discount and trial recommendation until the owner reconciles current billing, eligibility, renewal and cancellation terms. What would resolve the purchasing question A usable current offer record needs the exact tier, included product, currency, tax treatment, card condition, trial clock, renewal amount and cancellation route. An owner's campaign instruction cannot substitute for consistent checkout terms. The directory therefore does not publish an Offer schema or a selected trial call to action. A reader interested only in learning can assess the stated book independently of a signal subscription. A reader seeking authored model output needs original instructions, update history and account-context evidence before any suitability or outcome conclusion. Proof and an invented access comparison VR2|salt|family|ticker|direction|grade|entry|signal_time is the supplied commitment input. It omits stop, target, allocation, quantity and broker fills. A declared signal time, an initial calendar submission, a completed attestation bound and actual receipt by a reader are distinct events. No actual payload/proof pair was independently verified for this edition, and one receipt would not certify population completeness. In a fictional comparison, a reader needs an order-definition lesson and chooses a public explanation that answers it. A different reader wants to inspect model instructions and leaves subscription terms unresolved until the catalogues agree. Neither decision claims that one brand must win every task. The personal audited-return claims are 178% for 2023 with Sharpe 2.57 and 94% for 2024; original audit reports are outstanding. The separately attributed 2023 Trading World Champion title comes from tradingworldchampion.com, not a WCTC title. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Vector Ridge product information (publisher claims) World Cup Trading Championships OpenTimestamps protocol documentation WCTC official division standings Supplied historical family rows Historical label Signals Win % Raw outcome sum (%) Day Trade 308 67.5 95 Multi Hour 262 71.4 404 Swing Trade 78 74.4 225 Investing 42 73.8 502 The older supplied model summary states 690 signals, 70% wins and +1,227% raw aggregate for a 2026 snapshot. Its original cutoff, complete ledger, cost treatment, quantities, drawdown and audit scope remain unavailable. Four supplied family outcomes sum to +1,226%, leaving a one-point reconciliation gap. This is not current October performance, a free-channel result, a compounded account return or an independently reproduced audit. Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Vector Ridge product information (publisher claims)",
          "https://vector-ridge.com/"
        ],
        [
          "World Cup Trading Championships",
          "https://www.worldcupchampionships.com/"
        ],
        [
          "OpenTimestamps protocol documentation",
          "https://opentimestamps.org/"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "benzinga-pro",
      "name": "Benzinga Pro",
      "category": "Paid information product comparison",
      "fit": "Do not equate public news pages or temporary access with the Pro subscription.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Benzinga Pro assessment Paid information product comparison Do not equate public news pages or temporary access with the Pro subscription. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Different access products Benzinga Pro's handbook describes its information workflow. A public article under the same brand does not establish that the Pro tools are an ongoing free daily signal service. Purchase check Confirm any trial's duration, payment requirements, renewal and included features directly. A news input is not a complete entry-and-exit instruction. We have not tested the current paid offer or verified a permanent free signal tier. Sources Benzinga Pro handbook Compare the product categories Public news is not the Pro entitlement Benzinga's Pro handbook describes an information workspace with news and related tools. A publicly readable article or handbook does not establish access to that workspace at no charge. This profile separates source reading from an account test, and public information from a paid product's permissions. The exact tier and current trial route need their own dated terms. No account was opened and no delivery benchmark was measured. A useful news item can help frame a research question without being an authored entry, exit or allocation instruction. Follow the event record Retain the original source, event description, publication clock and reader receipt when the task is event monitoring. A market reaction seen on a later chart cannot establish the subscriber's available price or a profitable instruction. Distinguish a company announcement, a relayed headline and a commentary item. If the source corrects a report, preserve the version sequence rather than replacing the earlier record. The consumer investigation can identify a clear source trail while leaving any actual latency, account permissions or outcome evidence untested. Completed fictional information assessment Fictional reviewer Kai can read a public article and identify its underlying event. He has not entered the Pro interface, observed its receipt clock or subscribed to any associated room. His learning record says that the public information answered a background question, while the premium workflow remains untested. There is no trade plan or fill in his packet, so he does not calculate a win rate from the stock's subsequent direction. That decision preserves useful public content without misrepresenting it as permanently free access to a different information product. What to compare next The appropriate alternative depends on the task: another primary event source for background research, another information product for a defined monitoring workflow, or a fully specified strategy if authored execution instructions are required. Put software, data and execution expense in separate buckets if they apply. The free-cost worksheet does not contain Benzinga tariffs or make a current checkout recommendation. A product's documented features are not a complete financial audit, and a marketing demo does not replace a consecutive observation record. The profile makes no invented star score, verified-user count or independent paid-trial claim. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Benzinga Pro handbook Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Benzinga Pro handbook",
          "https://www.benzinga.com/pro/handbook-3"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "trade-ideas",
      "name": "Trade Ideas",
      "category": "Scanning-product comparison",
      "fit": "A tool demonstration or trial is not evidence of an unrestricted free live signal feed.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Trade Ideas assessment Scanning-product comparison A tool demonstration or trial is not evidence of an unrestricted free live signal feed. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Offer identity Read the specific product guide and current access terms. A scanner alert differs from a trade recommendation, and a demonstration differs from the paid product. Retained sample If a trial is available, document what it actually lets the user observe and how long access lasts. Do not publish a made-up free tier or use a selected historical chart as a free-feed return record. No hands-on trial was performed for this profile. Sources Trade Ideas product guide Compare the product categories A scanning workflow, not an unrestricted free feed Trade Ideas' public guide is a place to identify its software workflow. Reading that guide does not establish an unrestricted no-charge live signal service. A scanner result, displayed strategy idea and complete authored instruction need different consumer records. This desk has not bought an account, operated its software or independently tested a model. The current selected feature and entitlement remain important: a demonstration is not a paid-tier activation, and a historical screenshot is not proof that a future visitor receives the same data or outputs. Save the scan definition A reproducible consumer exercise retains the universe, filters, settings, source data context and observation time. A result list is not enough to identify which rules generated it. When settings change, keep the versions separate instead of attributing later successes to an earlier unspecified configuration. If an output lacks entry or invalidation information, note the omission rather than adding a convenient trading rule afterwards. The resulting evidence can explain whether the software addresses a scanning question while leaving execution quality and profitability unvalidated. Completed fictional scope finding Invented reviewer Sofia wants a candidate list meeting a declared filter, not a claim that every candidate should be bought. She retains a hypothetical filter version and the list it produced. The example has no market prices, quantities or account fills. Her conclusion is that the saved configuration would permit a later reproducibility check; it does not establish free permanent access or a profitable strategy. She separately names unknown entitlement and historical-export questions. A list that helps organise research can be useful without being transformed into a measured trading-signal record. Current access and total expense Before relying on a workflow, inspect official current tier and access terms for that exact feature. Do not assume a guide, trial, public demonstration or simulation provides the whole production experience. Include any applicable software, data and execution costs only when documented or explicitly hypothetical. A low cost per candidate is not a profitability measure because a candidate is not automatically an actionable instruction. Compare tools against the same scanning task and population, not a universal vendor leaderboard. This review offers no fabricated account trial, reviewer panel or provider-return score. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Trade Ideas product guide Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Trade Ideas product guide",
          "https://www.trade-ideas.com/guide/"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "mql5-signals",
      "name": "MQL5 Signals",
      "category": "Marketplace and copied-account subscriptions",
      "fit": "Access terms belong to the selected provider, not one universal 'free signals' label.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "MQL5 Signals assessment Marketplace and copied-account subscriptions Access terms belong to the selected provider, not one universal 'free signals' label. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. One offer at a time The MetaTrader subscriber guide explains a copying framework. Identify the chosen provider and its actual subscription terms before calling it free; a marketplace name is not one offer. Account costs remain Even a zero-fee provider would not remove broker costs or copying constraints. Keep provider history and the subscriber's execution apart. This desk has not established an ongoing free tier for every listed account or audited its performance. Sources MetaTrader signal subscriber documentation Compare the product categories Selected publisher and copied-account workflow MetaTrader's subscription documentation describes a signal-following workflow whose actual conditions concern a selected provider and account. That is different from reading a public article or receiving a manually interpreted chat post. The profile does not describe every marketplace subscription as free or assume identical access across accounts. Documentation reading is not a successful subscription or copy test. Keep the provider's source record, platform configuration and subscriber account context distinct before interpreting any displayed performance or access claim. Settings are consumer decisions Retain the chosen provider, relevant platform and account context, allocation settings, subscription dates and the stated copy conditions. An upstream provider outcome is not automatically the follower's outcome. A reader's quantities, symbol availability, timing and expenses would be separate evidence in a real assessment. This publication supplies none of those from a live subscriber account and makes no personal sizing recommendation. The absence of a subscription charge, if actually documented for a selected offer, would still leave account execution risk and external costs outside the zero-price label. A completed invented entitlement comparison Fictional researcher Omar can read a publisher's public statistics but has not activated a subscription. His record marks public visibility as observed and copy execution as untested. He leaves the selected provider's current price, eligible account and renewal terms unresolved rather than borrowing another listing's offer. There are no broker orders or account outcomes in the case. The decision is useful because it identifies the next evidence needed without converting a public profile into a claim that a free automated trading service was successfully operated. Comparison and evidence limits A fair comparison names the same follow task and observation window across selected offers. Preserve the original instructions or upstream sequence where available, then inspect subscriber evidence separately. Do not calculate a personal future return from a public leaderboard or equate a zero fee with a safe account configuration. Exact eligibility and terms must come from current official sources for the chosen workflow. The desk has not reviewed every marketplace publisher, audited a complete history or established universal no-charge access. There are no invented user reviews or numerical vendor ranks. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. MetaTrader signal subscriber documentation Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "MetaTrader signal subscriber documentation",
          "https://www.metatrader5.com/en/terminal/help/signals/signal_subscriber"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "learn2trade",
      "name": "Learn 2 Trade",
      "category": "Forex signal instructions and education",
      "fit": "Compare the exact public or paid offer, with limitations and record availability stated.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Learn 2 Trade assessment Forex signal instructions and education Compare the exact public or paid offer, with limitations and record availability stated. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Name the access route The cited forex instructions describe interpreting signals. They do not prove that every advertised channel is permanently free or provides the same message volume and history. Missing records Ask whether losing and cancelled calls remain available and whether the free channel differs from the paid one. This review neither confirms a current free-channel schedule nor invents a user count, return or ongoing entitlement. Sources Learn 2 Trade signal instructions Compare the product categories Instructions and the exact access route Learn 2 Trade's signal-use material is included as a source for understanding the advertised instruction workflow. It is not evidence that every room, message, update or archive is permanently free. Name the particular access route and distinguish publicly readable education from any selected commercial offer. This desk has not joined a room, tested delivery or audited outcomes. A public guide can explain the intended message format while leaving actual entitlement, historical coverage and subscriber use unresolved. Preserve the instruction as issued For an actual review, retain pair identity, direction, entry convention, validity and every update the source supplies. Do not complete omitted fields after seeing the market outcome. Keep incomplete, late, cancelled and unfilled items visible in the observation population. If the study needs post-entry updates that a free sample does not show, record that limitation explicitly. Equally, do not assume every public item is incomplete or accuse the source of deleting losses without evidence. The consumer question is what the chosen route provides and what its record supports. A completed fictional message assessment Invented reader Nia encounters a public description and a hypothetical sample instruction. The sample names a pair and direction but omits a validity rule needed by her planned execution study. She retains the sample and classifies it as insufficient for that task; it may still be useful for learning the message vocabulary. The example includes no price outcome, broker account or vendor trial. Nia therefore does not claim a winning percentage or a complete subscriber workflow from one sample, and she does not turn an omission into an unsupported misconduct allegation. Access and outside commitments The actual offer should state included content, registration requirements, duration, recurring charges and any outside-account condition. Save those terms rather than assuming a common policy for every channel under the brand. If a broker referral is involved, the relationship and account commitments need their own records. A deposit is not automatically a content fee, and an educational page is not an account-safety audit. Compare actual instructions on the same task and observation window. Current price, live profitability and complete archive claims remain unverified in this documentation-based profile. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Learn 2 Trade signal instructions Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Learn 2 Trade signal instructions",
          "https://learn2.trade/using-our-forex-signals"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "zulutrade",
      "name": "ZuluTrade",
      "category": "Social account-copying reference",
      "fit": "No-fee marketing does not establish zero account or execution costs.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "ZuluTrade assessment Social account-copying reference No-fee marketing does not establish zero account or execution costs. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Separate the bill The platform's public offer must be read alongside the chosen broker, trader and account arrangement. A headline about access cannot supply the full transaction or financing bill. What this review establishes This is an adjacent product reference, not certification of a free daily feed. We have not opened an account, measured copying results or confirmed a universal free entitlement. Ask for dated terms and a specific account route. Sources ZuluTrade product site Compare the product categories An account-following reference ZuluTrade presents a social trading and account-following product. Its public descriptions help identify the kind of workflow, but they do not establish that every eligible combination has zero cost. A public profile, a subscription or platform entitlement and actual account execution are distinct objects. The desk has not opened an account, selected a trader or measured copying. This directory includes the product as an adjacent comparison rather than calling it a free daily instruction feed or an independently tested profitable alternative. Who owns each obligation A useful purchasing record names the platform, selected strategy or trader, account provider and payment recipient. Eligibility, fees and commercial relationships should be checked for the exact route. Do not infer the reader's jurisdiction, account protections or current deposit condition from a general homepage. Legal independence of a content publisher does not eliminate referral questions. Save the source and date for any stated requirement; missing conditions remain open. The site offers no broker safety ranking or legal conclusion about an account arrangement it has not operated. Completed fictional workflow record Fictional visitor Luca can inspect a public product description but has no account record. He marks the public material as observed, selected trader access as unresolved and subscriber execution as untested. The example includes no deposit, copy allocation, fills or cost evidence. His conclusion is that he can describe the proposed workflow but cannot call it a completed free setup or forecast a personal return. This preserves what the public source genuinely establishes while preventing a familiar brand name from standing in for account-specific evidence. Costs and financial outcomes A provider's displayed record does not automatically translate into a follower's result. A real assessment needs the chosen account context, quantities, timing, fees and changes to settings in addition to upstream evidence. The cost worksheet can keep hypothetical monthly expenses explicit, but it does not create any of those account records. Comparing selected follow workflows requires matched periods and definitions, not an invented universal best-provider score. No user-review dataset, paid-account trial or independently reproduced return calculation was supplied for this profile. Current specific entitlements should be confirmed directly before a consumer decision. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. ZuluTrade product site Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "ZuluTrade product site",
          "https://www.zulutrade.com/"
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "slug": "cryptohopper",
      "name": "Cryptohopper",
      "category": "Crypto automation and marketplace reference",
      "fit": "Software, marketplace signals and execution may have separate costs; confirm the chosen combination.",
      "core": false,
      "sections": [
        [
          "Expanded visible consumer edition",
          "Cryptohopper assessment Crypto automation and marketplace reference Software, marketplace signals and execution may have separate costs; confirm the chosen combination. Original documentation review: 7 October 2026. Expanded source review: 13 October 2026. No purchased account trial or independently reproduced provider performance is represented. Components can differ The signal marketplace is not the whole access bill for running an automated crypto workflow. Identify the software tier, selected signal source and exchange conditions independently. Avoid a false free label A trial, sample or publicly visible listing cannot establish an indefinitely free operational setup. This desk has not deployed a bot or tested an ongoing zero-cost offer. Retain actual plan terms instead of filling a comparison table with invented prices. Sources Cryptohopper signal marketplace Compare the product categories Marketplace access and software are different Cryptohopper's signal marketplace is a public route to inspect listed offers. That does not establish that all publisher subscriptions, automation features and exchange activity are included free. The useful comparison names the selected signal source and software tier separately. This desk has not purchased a listing, connected an exchange or measured automated execution. It therefore describes the documented workflow and unresolved entitlements rather than presenting an unrestricted free bot service or a certified profitable trading stack. Identity before integration Retain the source publisher, asset and pair context, venue if specified, message validity and the settings used to interpret an output. An asset label alone may not identify the exact instrument the reader would trade. Preserve configuration versions and cancellations rather than retrospectively completing an instruction after a favourable chart move. A public listing can help define an investigation while leaving history completeness, delivery and outcome evidence missing. Those gaps are not permission to invent losing trades or a numerical quality score. Completed fictional cost case Fictional researcher Ren considers a public message route with separate hypothetical software and execution costs. Eight usable monitoring items in the chosen invented month accompany $20 software and $12 execution assumptions, giving $4 per item. This is not a current Cryptohopper tariff, measured bill or strategy return. No exchange credentials or orders are included. The record shows how a zero message price can coexist with a positive workflow expense while leaving the actual publisher's offer, software entitlement and account outcomes untested. Permissions and comparison limits Account permissions and revocation need their own official information if a reader later considers integration. Secrets do not belong in a consumer workbench, downloaded case packet or source file. This site's tools do not connect accounts or submit orders. A real provider study would retain the original message population and account evidence separately, including duplicates, incomplete items and execution costs. Compare the same task and period across selected offers, not the entire marketplace as one provider. No tested free access, user-review population or independent account-performance certification is represented in this profile. Primary references and their limits Public documents reviewed 13 October 2026. A link supports its stated mechanism or access description, not a completed account trial or this desk's invented case. Cryptohopper signal marketplace Free-resource investigations Search the whole publication"
        ]
      ],
      "sources": [
        [
          "Cryptohopper signal marketplace",
          "https://www.cryptohopper.com/marketplace/signals"
        ]
      ]
    }
  ],
  "guides": [
    {
      "path": "guides/free-data-alerts-trials-and-signals.html",
      "title": "Free data, alerts, trials and trade signals",
      "description": "A consumer map of no-fee resources, limited product tiers and temporary access, with no invented list of free profitable providers.",
      "sources": [
        [
          "TradingView plan comparison",
          "https://www.tradingview.com/pricing/"
        ],
        [
          "Investor.gov investor education",
          "https://www.investor.gov/"
        ],
        [
          "CME education courses",
          "https://www.cmegroup.com/education/courses"
        ],
        [
          "FRED API documentation",
          "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/"
        ]
      ],
      "sections": [
        [
          "Classify the resource first",
          "Before comparing 'free signals', ask what is being delivered. A public economic observation is data. An educational article explains a concept. A configured chart alert reports that a condition occurred. A trade instruction proposes an action with its own validity and risk rules. These objects can all help research, but they cannot share one performance ranking. A useful directory states the product type and missing decisions rather than converting every free resource into a signal provider with an invented score."
        ],
        [
          "No fee does not mean no limit",
          "A free tier may restrict alerts, history, instruments, data freshness or notification routes. Check the supplier's current plan page and preserve the date. TradingView, for example, lists different alert categories and plan entitlements; do not assume that a free account includes every technical condition. A publicly visible article under a paid brand is also not evidence that its subscription tools are free. An access comparison needs the specific feature the reader wants, not just the word 'free' on a sign-up screen."
        ],
        [
          "A trial is temporary access",
          "Write down when a trial begins, what it includes, whether payment details are required, when billing can start and how cancellation works. Do not invent an answer where the seller's terms are absent. A 14-day trial is not an indefinitely free feed. Save the original offer and ask whether old messages and unresolved outcomes remain accessible afterward. A short period can reveal operational fit without proving profitability, especially when positions may last beyond the access window."
        ],
        [
          "Education can stand on its own",
          "Investor.gov and CME education are useful because a reader can learn order and contract concepts without accepting a seller's performance pitch. That value does not depend on pretending they supply buy and sell calls. A free book with email opt-in is another education offer, but its marketing, privacy and delivery terms need their own check. Do not silently bundle education into a signal ranking or assume that reading material proves the author's subscription results."
        ],
        [
          "Keep the complete cost picture",
          "A zero subscription fee does not eliminate software, data, commissions, spreads, financing or losses. Some workflows require an account or another paid component to make the instruction usable. Use dated assumptions for the complete observed period and keep charges separate by component. The cost worksheet divides entered monthly costs by an entered usable-item count; it does not infer profit, quality or a recommended allocation. A low cost per item is allowed to coexist with an unhelpful feed."
        ],
        [
          "Demand usable instructions",
          "For a feed that really does issue trade calls, retain instrument identity, direction, validity, entry convention and exit or cancellation rules. Preserve delivery and later changes separately from declared signal time. A daily post can be too late to use, and an edited winner can lack the original information needed to reconstruct it. Keep expired and unfilled instructions in the observation sequence. Avoid selecting only attractive examples and then claiming the full free channel has been tested."
        ],
        [
          "Make the conclusion precise",
          "A dated assessment can say 'free public education', 'limited chart tier', 'paid alternative' or 'access terms not established'. That is more useful than a universal top pick covering unlike products. State which documents were inspected and which accounts were not tested. Do not promise unchanged access, search ranking or future returns. When the evidence stops at a product description, keep the conclusion at that level and tell the reader exactly what to confirm before sharing personal data or paying."
        ],
        [
          "Keep your own observation evidence",
          "Preserve the original access page, actual notifications and the reason each item qualified as usable. Note whether the comparison was based only on documentation or on observations you personally retained. Do not create a testimonial from that exercise unless it reflects a real identified experience. A record of unclear or unavailable information can be valuable without turning uncertainty into a fabricated negative review."
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "path": "guides/free-feed-freshness-and-revision-audit.html",
      "title": "Free-feed freshness and revision audit",
      "description": "Separate observation dates, release times, receipt times and later edits before deciding whether a free resource was actionable.",
      "sources": [
        [
          "ALFRED real-time and vintage data",
          "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/alfred.html"
        ],
        [
          "TradingView alert documentation",
          "https://www.tradingview.com/support/solutions/43000520149-introduction-to-tradingview-alerts/"
        ],
        [
          "FRED API documentation",
          "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/"
        ]
      ],
      "sections": [
        [
          "Four clocks",
          "Record the date a value describes, when its source published it, when the feed delivered it and when the reader observed it. They can differ. A post labelled with an old market date does not prove it was available then. Use an explicit time zone and keep the original identifier rather than trying to reconstruct chronology from a screenshot taken later."
        ],
        [
          "Economic revisions",
          "ALFRED's vintage-data documentation helps distinguish later revisions from earlier available economic observations. When a signal claim relies on a macro value, retain the relevant vintage or original source publication where possible. A current value inserted into an old trading explanation may contain hindsight. This does not automatically establish fraud, but it changes what the evidence can support."
        ],
        [
          "Alert expiration",
          "Check whether an alert was active, delayed or expired when the event occurred. A chart condition visible afterward is not automatically a delivered message. Preserve the configured rule, author and version with the actual notification. Do not generalise one plan's alert limits or expiration rules to every tier or source."
        ],
        [
          "Append, do not replace",
          "Save the original instruction and link subsequent revisions to it. If the provider deletes a message, preserve the observation that the record became unavailable without inventing its contents. Include losing, cancelled and unfilled ideas in the same dated sample. A small retained sample may reveal a process problem, but does not justify a blanket accusation about every free channel."
        ],
        [
          "Report what was usable",
          "At the period cutoff, separate on-time actionable messages, late information, educational posts and incomplete instructions. State your definitions before counting. An item is not 'usable' merely because its chart later rose. A freshness audit can inform a purchase decision without being a profit study; keep that limitation visible in the exported journal or cost scenario."
        ],
        [
          "A source handoff",
          "When a free channel relays another author's message, retain the original source where available and the relay's receipt time. An aggregator's later post is not proof of the original publication. If the source cannot be recovered, record that limitation rather than assigning a stronger timestamp."
        ]
      ]
    },
    {
      "path": "guides/free-signal-hidden-cost-and-handoff.html",
      "title": "Free-signal costs and workflow handoff",
      "description": "Map the steps between a no-fee message and an actual account action, including software, data, execution and renewal boundaries.",
      "sources": [
        [
          "TradingView plan comparison",
          "https://www.tradingview.com/pricing/"
        ],
        [
          "MetaTrader signal subscriber documentation",
          "https://www.metatrader5.com/en/terminal/help/signals/signal_subscriber"
        ],
        [
          "FINRA stop-order risks",
          "https://www.finra.org/investors/insights/stop-orders-factors-consider-during-volatile-markets"
        ]
      ],
      "sections": [
        [
          "Map the handoff",
          "Write down who originates the idea, where the message appears, how the buyer sees it and what turns it into an order. A feed that is free to read may still require a paid chart, data connection or software tier for the desired workflow. Keep each supplier and entitlement separate instead of calling the whole chain free."
        ],
        [
          "Count one period",
          "Use the same calendar month for subscriptions, data, software and observed execution costs. Mark estimates as estimates and avoid counting the same charge in two buckets. Charges per side and round trip are different units. This site has no current broker tariff for the reader's account and does not supply one from memory."
        ],
        [
          "Define useful before dividing",
          "Decide what qualifies as a usable item before calculating a cost per item. An educational article, a late notification and a complete trade instruction should not automatically share a denominator. With zero usable items, the per-item cost is undefined, not zero or infinite as a provider score. The worksheet exposes that state without turning it into an accusation."
        ],
        [
          "Retain account outcomes separately",
          "A provider's hypothetical entry and an actual account fill may differ. Save execution costs and missed or rejected actions rather than assuming the advertised price was attainable. Stop execution can differ from its trigger price. Do not combine an illustrative cost calculation with a real account return unless the underlying records justify every component."
        ],
        [
          "Check the next bill",
          "If the workflow includes a trial or discounted period, preserve the renewal amount and cancellation route from the dated terms. Confirm whether access to history remains afterward. Do not describe the first month's temporary access as a permanent no-fee offer. A useful conclusion can be that a free resource is valuable for research while the operational trading setup remains paid and untested."
        ],
        [
          "Currency and units",
          "If the bill includes multiple currencies, document the conversion date and rate used outside the worksheet. Its inputs are USD totals. Keep per-contract, per-side and monthly amounts in their original units before converting them; a familiar dollar symbol does not make the units comparable."
        ]
      ]
    }
  ],
  "rebuild": [
    [
      "methodology.html",
      "How free resources are assessed",
      "Access type and practical value before any provider ranking.",
      [
        [
          "Compare like with like",
          "Separate education, economic data, chart conditions, trade calls and copied accounts. A free learning resource need not be a signal publisher to be useful. A paid alternative can be described without being mislabelled a permanent free feed."
        ],
        [
          "Dated access",
          "Check the specific feature and offer, including limits, data freshness, payment requirements and trial expiry. Save the current terms instead of guaranteeing them forever. Where ongoing free access is not established, say so."
        ],
        [
          "Retained observations",
          "A trade-feed evaluation needs original instructions, revisions, delivery times and consecutive statuses. Cost comparisons use the same observed period and a defined usable-item count. Cost per item is not a return metric or a quality rating."
        ],
        [
          "Evidence limits",
          "The desk reads primary sources but did not test paid accounts or certify a complete vendor history. No real user-rating dataset was provided; invented stars and review counts are excluded. A precise access classification is more defensible than declaring unlike products one universal winner."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "faq.html",
      "Free-signal questions",
      "What is actually free, and what evidence remains missing?",
      [
        [
          "Is free education a free signal?",
          "No. A book, article or course can teach useful concepts without providing an executable trade. The directory names that difference instead of fabricating a signal history for educational publishers."
        ],
        [
          "Is a free trial permanently free?",
          "No. Record its duration, included access, billing requirements and cancellation route directly from the seller. Do not assume a refund or ongoing access to unresolved outcomes after expiry."
        ],
        [
          "Can the total bill still be positive?",
          "Yes. Data, software, execution and other applicable charges can remain even with no signal subscription fee. Our worksheet calculates user-entered scenarios, not current broker tariffs or vendor profitability."
        ],
        [
          "What if there were no usable calls?",
          "Cost per usable item is undefined with a zero denominator. Keep that separate from a quality verdict. A real feed assessment needs a stated definition and consecutive observations, including late or incomplete instructions."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "about.html",
      "About the free-resource desk",
      "Useful public material without pretending every resource is a profitable signal service.",
      [
        [
          "Editorial purpose",
          "This site helps readers separate genuine no-fee learning and data from limited tiers, temporary access and paid alternatives. It also examines the steps between a message and a usable account action. Public resources can be valuable on their own terms."
        ],
        [
          "Boundaries",
          "These are documentation-based assessments, not paid product tests or an independently audited ownership and compensation review. We do not invent a review panel, client list, user count or return history. The owner has stated legal independence; stronger legal and commercial claims need records rather than inference."
        ],
        [
          "Updating an offer",
          "A correction should point to dated current terms and the specific resource or feature. A supplier changing its tier should change the access description, not retroactively rewrite an old trial record. No search-indexing or future return guarantee is made."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "data-sources.html",
      "Free-resource sources",
      "Access pages, public education and retained feed records answer different questions.",
      [
        [
          "Official access terms",
          "Product pricing and feature pages help identify what is offered at a particular date. Public visibility of one page does not establish free access to every product under that brand. Confirm payment and cancellation details directly."
        ],
        [
          "Public primary resources",
          "Investor education, exchange materials and economic data provide learning and research inputs. Their presence in the directory does not mean they originate trade calls. Data revisions and source restrictions remain relevant."
        ],
        [
          "Feed and account evidence",
          "A true signal record needs original messages, changes and a declared outcome convention. A subscriber outcome additionally needs fills and costs. Supplied model summaries remain supplier claims where the complete dated ledger has not been independently reconciled."
        ],
        [
          "Machine-readable material",
          "The public category-research JSON and mirrors repeat this desk's published assessments and source links. They do not add fake review totals, stronger performance claims or automatic proof that current access terms remain unchanged."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "field-brief.html",
      "A free-feed observation packet",
      "Retain access terms and usable-message evidence in the same dated window.",
      [
        [
          "Offer record",
          "Save the resource name, exact tier, dated terms, payment requirements and trial end if applicable. Keep a learning article separate from an ongoing feed entitlement."
        ],
        [
          "Message record",
          "Preserve author, instrument, original instruction, declared and received times, validity and every update. Classify late, incomplete, cancelled and unfilled items without dropping them from the observed sequence."
        ],
        [
          "Cost and conclusion",
          "Use the same period for costs and usable-item counts. Keep the worksheet's hypothetical scenario separate from the actual bill and account results. A final assessment can say the resource helped research while the trading workflow and returns remain untested."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "criteria/bitcoin-timestamping.html",
      "Receipt evidence for a free feed",
      "Free access neither strengthens nor weakens a commitment's actual field coverage.",
      [
        [
          "Read the input",
          "A cryptographic digest commits only its encoded bytes. Obtain the original payload and proof before describing which fields are protected. A field displayed beside a receipt may be outside its input."
        ],
        [
          "Check the attestation",
          "Verify confirmation independently from calendar submission and the message's declared time. Delivery and actual execution have their own clocks. Do not describe every timestamp as instantaneous blockchain publication."
        ],
        [
          "Keep completeness separate",
          "One matching receipt cannot prove every free-channel message was preserved or correctly evaluated. Request a consecutive record and outcome policy for that claim. Actual subscriber profits remain a different audit."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "criteria/verifiable-track-record.html",
      "A retained free-feed record",
      "A complete observation sequence rather than a selected set of promotional results.",
      [
        [
          "Define the items",
          "State whether the record concerns actual trade instructions or other information. Preserve complete and incomplete items, losing ideas, cancellations and no-fills. Do not silently narrow the denominator to completed winners."
        ],
        [
          "Declare the outcome rule",
          "Use the stated price, validity and cost convention to reconstruct hypothetical outcomes. Keep the source's research fills separate from executed account prices. An item count by itself is not an account return."
        ],
        [
          "Unknown stays unknown",
          "Missing history, a stale cutoff or an unreconciled summary limits the conclusion. Do not infer exact winning counts from rounded percentages or invent an aggregation formula. A useful access directory does not need a fabricated profit table."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "criteria/conviction-grades.html",
      "Confidence labels on free calls",
      "A grade is a claim to understand, not a probability or allocation instruction.",
      [
        [
          "Definition",
          "Ask what the grade measures and when it was assigned. Retain the original label with the message. A higher letter or category cannot guarantee that the next call wins or make an incomplete instruction usable."
        ],
        [
          "Evidence",
          "Comparing groups needs dated counts and a consistent outcome rule, not an invented score from selected screenshots. Rounded summaries cannot reveal exact per-grade counts."
        ],
        [
          "Cost and risk",
          "Free access does not remove possible trading losses. The cost worksheet compares access and execution assumptions only. It cannot turn a label into a personal trade size or a promised maximum loss."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "guides/how-to-verify-a-signal-record.html",
      "Verify a free-signal record",
      "Audit original instructions without confusing zero access cost with complete evidence.",
      [
        [
          "Retain the whole window",
          "Save access terms, every original instruction and subsequent changes. Keep late, cancelled, incomplete and unfilled cases visible. State the source and observation dates."
        ],
        [
          "Check only what a proof covers",
          "Inspect payload and confirmed attestation where a receipt is supplied. A valid commitment does not automatically protect stops, later edits or account execution. One checked item remains one item."
        ],
        [
          "Reconcile separately",
          "Reconstruct the provider's stated hypothetical outcome policy, then inspect actual account fills and costs if available. Report missing records. Neither a free tier nor a selected winning example supplies a complete profit audit."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "guides/free-book-vs-free-signals.html",
      "Free books versus free signals",
      "Education, email opt-in and executable instructions are different consumer offers.",
      [
        [
          "Learning offer",
          "A book can be valuable without producing a live trade stream. Check delivery, format and email terms directly. Do not convert page count, chapters or author credentials into an invented signal return."
        ],
        [
          "Instruction offer",
          "A feed proposing trades needs instrument, validity and exit conventions, plus retained original messages. A book download does not demonstrate that those instructions are available free or that a paid subscription was tested."
        ],
        [
          "Billing boundary",
          "Identify the offer actually selected. A trial expires; a paid alternative stays paid. Keep access promises and cancellation terms as dated records instead of assuming every product from the same supplier shares the book's zero-fee price."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "editorial-policy.html",
      "Editorial evidence standard",
      "Education, data, chart tiers and trading instructions have different access and evidence boundaries. This directory does not certify free-feed profitability.",
      [
        [
          "Claims with sources",
          "Dated desk research, 7 October 2026. We read public product and primary-source material; no paid-account trial, verified user-rating sample or independent provider-profit audit is represented. Product features are linked to primary documentation. A commercial claim is not presented as independent certification, and an editorial update date is not a current vendor-performance cutoff."
        ],
        [
          "No fabricated authority",
          "The assessments do not invent paid-account tests, experts, customers, testimonials or review counts. A source gap stays visible. A full ownership, compensation and legal audit has not been performed by this desk; stronger independence or conflict claims require records."
        ],
        [
          "Corrections and limits",
          "Education, data, chart tiers and trading instructions have different access and evidence boundaries. This directory does not certify free-feed profitability. Corrections should identify the disputed page, dated source and exact claim it supports. We do not promise indexation, search rank or future returns from publishing deeper material."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "criteria/index.html",
      "Free-resource evidence checklist",
      "Access and record questions tailored to what the resource supplies.",
      [
        [
          "Access type",
          "Separate public education, data, limited chart tiers and temporary trials. A paid signal alternative should stay labelled paid, even when the same publisher has free learning material."
        ],
        [
          "Retained record",
          "For actual trade calls, inspect consecutive messages, revisions and outcome rules. Do not accuse every no-fee channel of deleting losses or infer that every paid timestamped desk is complete."
        ],
        [
          "Total cost and usefulness",
          "Compare dated costs with a predefined usable-item count. A zero subscription fee cannot prove profit or remove execution risk. A public data series can be valuable without being a predictive signal."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "guides/free-signal-red-flags.html",
      "Free-offer gaps to investigate",
      "Dated terms and specific missing records before a consumer verdict.",
      [
        [
          "Unclear access promise",
          "A 'free' banner without feature limits, payment requirements or expiry needs clarification. Request the exact offer instead of assuming unrestricted access or automatic billing."
        ],
        [
          "Incomplete instruction history",
          "Selected winners and unavailable losing messages do not support a full accuracy claim. Ask for the complete observation sequence, including late, cancelled and unfilled items. Missing evidence is not permission to invent the missing outcomes."
        ],
        [
          "Costs hidden by the label",
          "A no-fee message may require data, software or execution charges. Map the workflow and the suppliers. Use real dated terms where available, with assumptions explicitly labelled."
        ],
        [
          "Avoid blanket accusations",
          "A public education site, chat feed and paid service have different purposes. A delivery format does not prove misconduct. This directory identifies unanswered questions without publishing made-up ratings or a predetermined profitable winner."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "guides/are-free-trading-signals-worth-it.html",
      "Are free market resources useful?",
      "Value can mean education or research access without implying a profitable trading instruction.",
      [
        [
          "Choose the task",
          "A resource may explain an order type, supply data or report a chart condition. Assess that actual benefit rather than demanding every free page be a signal service."
        ],
        [
          "Check usability",
          "Confirm freshness, limits and the complete instruction where an action is proposed. Record late or incomplete messages honestly. A public post viewed after a move is not automatically an actionable earlier call."
        ],
        [
          "Count the bill",
          "No-fee access can coexist with software, data and trading costs. The worksheet uses entered monthly assumptions and a defined usable-item count. It does not generate a vendor return or quality rating."
        ],
        [
          "Bound the verdict",
          "Documentation can establish a resource category and an offer's stated limits. A retained trial can reveal workflow fit. Neither alone certifies durable profitability. This desk has not tested paid accounts or guaranteed that current access terms remain unchanged."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "guides/index.html",
      "Free-resource research guides",
      "Classify offers, inspect freshness and keep the whole workflow bill visible.",
      [
        [
          "Access before accuracy",
          "Start with the resource taxonomy so public learning, data and temporary trials do not collapse into one false signal ranking."
        ],
        [
          "Chronology and revisions",
          "The freshness audit distinguishes observation, publication, receipt and later edits. The original source matters when a channel relays another author's content."
        ],
        [
          "Practical costs",
          "The handoff guide and worksheet expose a positive bill even when subscriptions are zero. Undefined cost per item with no usable observations stays undefined, not a fabricated provider score."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "glossary.html",
      "Free-resource glossary",
      "Definitions used by this research desk, with product and evidence boundaries made explicit.",
      [
        [
          "Free tier and trial",
          "A free tier has specified ongoing limits at a stated date. A trial provides temporary access. Neither promises every feature, instrument or historical record."
        ],
        [
          "Education and data",
          "An educational resource explains concepts; a data source supplies observations. Both can be useful without publishing trade instructions or a measurable signal history."
        ],
        [
          "Trade instruction",
          "An actionable call needs an instrument, direction, validity and a defined entry and exit convention. An incomplete or late message should not acquire a hindsight fill."
        ],
        [
          "Usable item",
          "For a cost comparison, define usable before counting the sample. With zero usable observations, cost per item is undefined. It is not a provider-quality score."
        ],
        [
          "Revision and receipt",
          "A revised post should remain linked to its original version. A cryptographic commitment protects only its input and needs verified attestation; it cannot certify omitted changes or a complete feed."
        ],
        [
          "Win rate and account result",
          "A percentage needs a dated denominator and outcome rule. Hypothetical signal results, subscription costs and actual account executions are different quantities; do not invent an aggregation formula."
        ]
      ]
    ],
    [
      "privacy.html",
      "Privacy and the cost worksheet",
      "What the current static publication and client-side worksheet do, without unverified promises about host retention.",
      [
        [
          "Worksheet inputs stay in its calculation",
          "The monthly-cost worksheet runs in the browser and has no broker connector or input-upload endpoint. Export creates a download of user-entered costs and calculated values. This publication has no account-registration form; it does not collect an email address for a book on these pages."
        ],
        [
          "A host still receives requests",
          "Cloudflare Pages receives web requests to serve the publication. The desk has not independently reviewed the exact logging, cookie and retention configuration. It therefore does not claim that ordinary browsing creates no operational record or that host logs are never used in a particular way."
        ],
        [
          "Linked offers have separate terms",
          "A product trial, book opt-in or data account at another site is a separate interaction. Read that supplier's current privacy and access terms before sharing information. Do not place credentials or personal notes in worksheet fields. This implementation notice is not a full legal or compliance audit."
        ]
      ]
    ]
  ],
  "legacy_corrections": [
    [
      "not an arithmetic|different bases|483|roughly.*wins|rounded.*(?:win|counts)",
      "A supplied Vector Ridge 2026 snapshot reports 690 signals, 70% wins and +1,227% raw aggregate, but the complete dated ledger and reconciliation are not available in this review. Do not present that summary as today's free-feed result, current October performance or a subscriber account return."
    ],
    [
      "(?:free|no.fee).*education tier|education tier.*free|top pick|#1|one desk|clears all|all five|only.*(?:pick|provider|service)|recommended (?:desk|service)",
      "Free education, free data and a free trial are different offers. Vector Ridge's book is stated to be free with email opt-in; its signals are paid subscriptions, not an established indefinitely free daily signal feed."
    ],
    [
      "most.*(?:fail|don't|cannot)|by.*(?:architecture|built)|category.*(?:fails|failure)|no verifiable denominator|never left up|trips several",
      "A no-fee chat feed can be useful or poor depending on its actual instructions and retained record. The absence of a subscription bill does not establish honest outcomes, and the delivery format alone does not establish dishonesty."
    ]
  ],
  "tool": {
    "kind": "free",
    "path": "tools/free-signal-cost-worksheet.html",
    "title": "Free-signal cost worksheet",
    "description": "Compare the total user-entered monthly bill with the number of items actually usable in the same period.",
    "fields": [
      {
        "name": "subscription",
        "label": "Signal subscriptions (USD/month)",
        "value": 0,
        "min": 0,
        "step": "any"
      },
      {
        "name": "data",
        "label": "Market data (USD/month)",
        "value": 0,
        "min": 0,
        "step": "any"
      },
      {
        "name": "software",
        "label": "Software (USD/month)",
        "value": 0,
        "min": 0,
        "step": "any"
      },
      {
        "name": "execution",
        "label": "Observed execution costs (USD/month)",
        "value": 15,
        "min": 0,
        "step": "any"
      },
      {
        "name": "other",
        "label": "Other applicable costs (USD/month)",
        "value": 10,
        "min": 0,
        "step": "any"
      },
      {
        "name": "usable",
        "label": "Usable observed items in that month",
        "value": 8,
        "min": 0,
        "step": 1
      }
    ],
    "sources": [
      [
        "TradingView plan comparison",
        "https://www.tradingview.com/pricing/"
      ],
      [
        "FINRA stop-order risks",
        "https://www.finra.org/investors/insights/stop-orders-factors-consider-during-volatile-markets"
      ]
    ],
    "sections": [
      [
        "The default scenario",
        "The example has no subscription, data or software charge, plus $15 of execution costs and $10 of other costs. Eight usable items make the $25 total equal $3.125 per item before display rounding. These are illustrative user inputs, not a supplier tariff or a measured free-feed bill."
      ],
      [
        "A zero-item result",
        "When no items were usable, the cost-per-item field remains undefined. A zero denominator must not create a fictional rating or a claim of zero cost. Define usable in advance and keep educational content separate from actionable instructions if the comparison concerns execution."
      ],
      [
        "Cost is not return",
        "The result does not include a strategy profit calculation, opportunity cost or every possible financing arrangement. You choose which applicable costs to enter. Do not duplicate a commission already counted elsewhere. A low per-item cost cannot establish a high-quality signal, and losses can exceed all the access costs shown."
      ],
      [
        "Export and privacy",
        "The export records the entered scenario and its arithmetic. It is not observed provider performance. The worksheet has no account connection or data upload; the calculation runs in the browser. Keep the scenario apart from a broker statement and retain the source of each charge when using it in a real purchasing comparison."
      ]
    ]
  },
  "editorial_note": "Education, data, chart tiers and trading instructions have different access and evidence boundaries. This directory does not certify free-feed profitability.",
  "general_proof": "Inspect the actual payload and confirmed proof. A receipt cannot protect omitted fields or establish every feed item, delivery event and account execution. No-fee access does not enlarge that evidential scope.",
  "critical_sources": [
    [
      "TradingView plan comparison",
      "https://www.tradingview.com/pricing/"
    ],
    [
      "ALFRED real-time and vintage data",
      "https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/alfred.html"
    ],
    [
      "FINRA stop-order risks",
      "https://www.finra.org/investors/insights/stop-orders-factors-consider-during-volatile-markets"
    ],
    [
      "OpenTimestamps protocol documentation",
      "https://opentimestamps.org/"
    ]
  ],
  "commercial_note": "This resource guide is educational, not a brokerage or signal seller. The desk has not independently verified affiliate or compensation arrangements.",
  "edition": "2026-10-13",
  "disclosure": "This publication supports discovery of trading resources and includes marketing context for Darren O'Neill and Vector Ridge. The owner states legally independent ownership. Legal independence does not establish the absence of editorial coordination, sponsorship, referrals or other material relationships; their exact arrangements have not been independently documented. No named independent testing panel, purchased product trial or user-review population is claimed. Product functions and unresolved access questions determine the comparison, not a universal financial winner."
}
